Monofilament or Braid? The Great Trolling Debate

Posted on

Monofilament or Braid? The Great Trolling Debate. Hello all fishing lovers, Today’s post is “Monofilament or Braid? The Great Trolling Debate”. i hope that this post is a good choice for you, all fishing lovers.

Monofilament or Braid? The Great Trolling Debate

By Mark Romanack

The Diver Rod shown here is rigged with Spectra braid (Maxima 8
Strand) because the low stretch and super thin diameter makes it
easier to fish divers at greater depths.

Jake and I stay pretty busy in the winter months doing fishing seminars at sport shows, fishing clubs, wild game dinners, in-store promotions and church events. One of the most common questions we get focuses on the best line types for trolling.

A decade ago this question would have been easy to answer because only a handful of credible anglers were trolling with braid in those days. Today, approximately 50% of anglers favor monofilament and the rest are in the braid camp. The reason so many anglers are switching to braid is because these lines have frankly gotten a lot better over the years. The early “braids” weren’t even actually braided lines, but rather fishing lines formed by fusing Microdyneema fibers.

Fused lines are super thin and they have very low stretch. The down side of these lines is they tend to have fairly low abrasion resistance, low knot strength and they load onto reel spools poorly because they are flat instead of round in shape like monofilament.

True “super braid” lines hit the market when Spectra fibers (similar to Microdyneema) were used to create fishing line by twisting these fibers into a true braided product. Braiding Spectra fibers into a fishing line creates a line that has a round shape similar to monofilament, exceptional abrasion resistance and these lines have awesome knot strength. Super braids are very thin in diameter and they also have near zero stretch.

At Fishing 411 our favorite “super braid” is made by Maxima and it’s called Braid 8. Formed by tightly braiding under pressure eight strands of Spectra fiber, this line also features a triple coated treatment that yields a much better casting and handling line.

Fishing multiple in-line boards per side of the
boat requires using monofilament line that is
user friendly to the line releases used on these
boards. The author recommends using premium
monofilament for this trolling application and his
favorite is Maxima Ultra Green.

We use braid when trolling larger diving planers such as the Slide-Diver, Lurk Disco Diver or Luhr Jensen Dipsy Diver. The ultra thin characteristics of braid helps these diving devices achieve maximum depth at the shortest possible lead lengths.

Typically when trolling with divers and braid we recommend using 40 or 50 pound test, but in some situations like walleye trolling 30 pound test is adequate.

A growing number of anglers are also using Spectra braids for trolling with a planer board mast system. Again because braid is ultra thin it allows these anglers to reach target depths with a minimum amount of line out.

Unfortunately Spectra braids are super slippery and this line type doesn’t function well with the rubber pinch pad style of line releases typically used when trolling with a mast system. The solution to this problem is to half hitch a rubber band around the braid and then place the rubber band into the line release.

When a fish is hooked the rubber band stretches and can be snapped free of the release by simply giving the rod tip a good snap. This set up works well for anyone who fishes a lot because super braids last and last. Even charter captains who fish every day are getting two and in some cases three seasons from set ups spooled with a quality braid!

Despite the fact that Spectra braids are becoming a major factor on the trolling scene, monofilament continues to be a work horse in this department. What makes monofilament so popular is the affordable cost, controlled stretch, exceptional abrasion resistance and amazing knot strength.

The biggest problem with monofilament is all brands and types are not created equal. A line that is designed to be limp and also to deliver great casting features is going to function very poorly as a trolling line. Trolling is hard on monofilament and the best choice here is a line designed with trolling in mind. Harder surfaced lines that have a little more memory and much greater abrasion resistance are required for trolling.

When it comes to choosing monofilament for trolling, the Fishing 411 staff highly recommends Maxima Ultra Green. This stuff is as tough as tough gets in a monofilament fishing line. Ultra Green is dependable even when it gets nicked up from hard use.

For some trolling situations like downrigger fishing, high quality
monofilament is the only practical choice. The Fishing 411 team
uses and recommends Maxima Ultra Green or Chameleon for
downrigger applications. This line is super abrasion resistant and
holds up well to the abuse of line releases.

Downrigger fishing is hard on fishing line. Ultra Green is so tough it holds up to the constant abuse dished out by line releases. Because Ultra Green is so tough, we tend to spool up with much lighter line than traditionally is used for rigger fishing.

Most captains who fish monofilament on riggers are spooling up with 25 pound test. With Ultra Green we recommend using 20 pound test for Great Lakes trout and salmon fishing and 15 pound test for browns, walleye and trout fishing on in-land lakes.

Another place that monofilament shines is among in-line board trollers. Because in-line boards are attached directly to the fishing line and several boards are typically stacked on each side of the boat, it’s critical to fish a line that functions flawlessly with a host of line release designs.

With the Off Shore Tackle OR12 Side-Planers we use on Fishing 411 this board features a line release on the tow arm and a line clip on the back of the board. Rigged in this manner, when a fish is hooked the line can be tripped from the tow arm release, allowing the board to spin in the water and remain attached to the line via the clip at the back of the board.

Once tripped the board stops planing to the side and drops back out of the board formation quickly, allowing the angler to stack multiple boards without having to clear lines to fight fish hooked on outside boards. Off Shore Tackle pioneered this rigging system which is hands down the most popular means of rigging and fishing in-line boards.

For walleye and brown trout trolling with in-line boards we recommend using 12 pound test Ultra Green which is approximately .013 in diameter.

Another area where monofilament is a clear choice is when bottom bouncer fishing for walleye. The natural stretch of monofilament functions perfectly when fishing bouncers and spinner rigs for structure loving walleye. Typically these rigs are fished as flat lines incorporating a fairly soft action rod. A little give in the line and a little give in the rod helps fool walleye into holding onto the bait long enough to get hooked.

Both 12 pound test Ultra Green and Chameleon are great monofilaments for fishing bottom bouncers. Ultra Green blends well in clear to stained waters and Chameleon disappears in stained to turbid water conditions.

These days modern fishing lines have some unique features worth exploring. Old school anglers who haven’t tried Spectra super braids should give these lines a solid look for certain trolling applications. While Spectra braids are expensive, they last much longer than monofilament helping to mitigate the cost.

Monofilament works great for lots of trolling situations, but it’s important to use hard surfaced lines designed with trolling in mind. If a line is advertised as being limp or having exceptional casting qualities, chances are it isn’t going to hold up to hard core trolling.

Article source:

Additional Tags for this post:
LARA WITH HORSE 2  |  https://yandex ru/clck/jsredir?from=yandex ru;search;web;;&text=&etext=1831 rQTt9eCSdr4ZmQk5WF71J6QwUHgv2Rg_61_BJcn1xeO_QFIAVPeqpG5--3h85ivt b066fc8c2d5ec659db68d39a65590fd7f86c4c13&uuid=&state=_BLhILn4SxNIvvL0W45KSic66uCIg23qh8iRG98qeIXme  |  Tonya Green Murder 1991  |  https://yandex ru/clck/jsredir?from=yandex ru;search;web;;&text=&etext=1835 wjeyaVlfSuU9ilZp63Wx5hZW-lv1_IjYtMCX0X38kK0nOkGFeEZfIsS9KtCL1ysL 5343850d78c8c3932e82c3a8e1b464347727f60f&uuid=&state=_BLhILn4SxNIvvL0W45KSic66uCIg23qh8iRG98qeIXme  |  https://yandex ru/clck/jsredir?from=yandex ru;search;web;;&text=&etext=1835 05SkBhWFqjo5irCWmSKTI3WFINnrtPfh5j6htIq9UUMV1OBzfZnkfj77o5CkmmPd a233ae673e90a84bad2e976570e26408a3ba8acb&uuid=&state=_BLhILn4SxNIvvL0W45KSic66uCIg23qh8iRG98qeIXme  |  https://yandex ru/clck/jsredir?from=yandex ru;search;web;;&text=&etext=1834 1LZYrw39wjEmdLXqvuulr_mh8v7jo0b9uNPp4fRT7HNGvrWtmwOsjhhCkeYBPe9b 07fd52906856b37ed7ab5ddd0fb23a7390bc046e&uuid=&state=_BLhILn4SxNIvvL0W45KSic66uCIg23qh8iRG98qeIXme  |  https://yandex ru/clck/jsredir?from=yandex ru;search;web;;&text=&etext=1833 Oz0VaoUpksQPWbMV947nhStqAt51aiS700Qal9XHSjEtNakuRSSDxm-GuFo1QGNw 83ad52694a0e594e2ac5fb7b1be52594b6b6f3b0&uuid=&state=_BLhILn4SxNIvvL0W45KSic66uCIg23qh8iRG98qeIXme  |  https://yandex ru/clck/jsredir?from=yandex ru;search;web;;&text=&etext=1833 OiJfm_auB8l7iZBiqqhmb2Fv5qWgerum9kH96YdyYcHopZUnYmKCJT5Odan-fjAH f90e9f6da2fe1814458e076e209e3f0d035f7641&uuid=&state=_BLhILn4SxNIvvL0W45KSic66uCIg23qh8iRG98qeIXme  |  https://yandex ru/clck/jsredir?from=yandex ru;search;web;;&text=&etext=1833 GsTsT7o6eJj8IKkKy8_bB7upkVrbCWYOI1OECdFT260l6oTtL5hOKBL0XwltSUiV 6f4e2b3bd2b96b333e3a65ca4b7f1518d2703df0&uuid=&state=_BLhILn4SxNIvvL0W45KSic66uCIg23qh8iRG98qeIXme  |  https://yandex ru/clck/jsredir?from=yandex ru;search;web;;&text=&etext=1833 cLs1hcQ-kJhrR5XsSaDeLCW3NBJkxEpjdS3YrskblHSLK_Jlwyo1pou-xzWy2RZO 64c06e132d958eed48c04fadf6e4386e95c72ce2&uuid=&state=_BLhILn4SxNIvvL0W45KSic66uCIg23qh8iRG98qeIXme  |  https://yandex ru/clck/jsredir?from=yandex ru;search;web;;&text=&etext=1832 v1edskIYsoVTgOm74IAT7yhyDC-spi4gtYMhsLdX9Xb8JviSTwEumRj73EiH5kcw 6c6065286f7c2cf2131855541a3ac80631d9b762&uuid=&state=_BLhILn4SxNIvvL0W45KSic66uCIg23qh8iRG98qeIXme  |  https://yandex ru/clck/jsredir?from=yandex ru;search;web;;&text=&etext=1821 QvrWuUVpgzKBNc8WssWTFUa_UvnPUnqt-80Rh4Rr6GSj7f8p9dsqgPvhhR5PRhBD 48fea64a96cedd8b07632cc33970a976c138de03&uuid=&state=_BLhILn4SxNIvvL0W45KSic66uCIg23qh8iRG98qeIXme  |  https://yandex ru/clck/jsredir?from=yandex ru;search;web;;&text=&etext=1830 tD8S9EZWwVPEsXKvl2j6nGKWPmWbfX0wNwAAdag0NywpWZmXHonGajY6QpoKJuRY a9d48558c789c319694d8e3ba03ed78793fd11f6&uuid=&state=_BLhILn4SxNIvvL0W45KSic66uCIg23qh8iRG98qeIXme  |  https://yandex ru/clck/jsredir?from=yandex ru;search;web;;&text=&etext=1829 qR0bB1Mfzi7Ft8qV_G2kBT3x33dtc62WE8GcYGR9d3uScefAye6kjHtqXntyJyMH 5f16bec100a760f88076bc5850e541c53c3b9fe0&uuid=&state=_BLhILn4SxNIvvL0W45KSic66uCIg23qh8iRG98qeIXme  |  https://yandex ru/clck/jsredir?from=yandex ru;search;web;;&text=&etext=1826 UnIiN9C3PKxDH11B2wTrW77Q1Jbnx5U9Plq3ny58yvA4cmdRBRH7KWPEIE8cc5pm 168291a83e6e2bf459ad1a6ec08b0d7083e710ce&uuid=&state=_BLhILn4SxNIvvL0W45KSic66uCIg23qh8iRG98qeIXme  |  https://yandex ru/clck/jsredir?from=yandex ru;search;web;;&text=&etext=1826 mlpgpQjyJWQxr-T4sxUk-N9YCgFp-X1yJmVY2A5DrS4frmc0rxeOs-zMHCsRAN8I 9aad60745bc5c35e1a4397e7d43ce098e75a9a97&uuid=&state=_BLhILn4SxNIvvL0W45KSic66uCIg23qh8iRG98qeIXme  |  https://yandex ru/clck/jsredir?from=yandex ru;search;web;;&text=&etext=1826 bUClRgFn9TUpRWJppa-wLmsd77A3vnWqXPXujzV8Na-I7Cd3cjSzTZqKNc6tpChg 9f534ad5127f46d3709a42d76ed12cf89c2c2d34&uuid=&state=_BLhILn4SxNIvvL0W45KSic66uCIg23qh8iRG98qeIXme  |  https://yandex ru/clck/jsredir?from=yandex ru;search;web;;&text=&etext=1824 RCftfSXfvxW-UAJ5mZX9Jp6LtMcVvIGEUnPu8ouz_gIdPc9Nb63m_f5PEtS69NQb f8fc9a66da9b2b2ba56f419cca000ab460c0de9d&uuid=&state=_BLhILn4SxNIvvL0W45KSic66uCIg23qh8iRG98qeIXme  |  https://yandex ru/clck/jsredir?from=yandex ru;search;web;;&text=&etext=1824 f8flmTZOZuMmTcbxaj9CCHkcfkTw4Y5xyBS0WZZJMCurpZGJDdrKxTKfvWxp_y3d f9f50e190a8c4e8c2e9b471c035d3ffa3c2ea04c&uuid=&state=_BLhILn4SxNIvvL0W45KSic66uCIg23qh8iRG98qeIXme  |  https://yandex ru/clck/jsredir?from=yandex ru;search;web;;&text=&etext=1823 w5yIn-BkomZ3eeumV19dQo9LFpP7xTW76AqG2lh9ft1plwYSmqK5rOoQkbFZqdrJ 93063994fc612ca581e72e1d90cd6c4cac3ab0aa&uuid=&state=_BLhILn4SxNIvvL0W45KSic66uCIg23qh8iRG98qeIXme  |  

May You Also Like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *